Integrational Needs

Providing commentry on the things that seperate South African from the rest of the world. One post at a time.

State of the South African Philosophy Graduate

Varsity Kid | 25 August, 2010 13:49

At risk of provoking those person(s) who share last names with certain musicians ; I question the state of the Philosophy Graduate in South Africa. Philosophy does not prepare you for any role in South Africa, it does nothing to boost your C.V. or highten your value in the eyes of South African employers.

So why should UCT students study Philosophy? The departmental website sells philosophy on the idea that studying it will increase and hone ones anayltical skills and thinking processes. "If one wants to learn to think clearly, to analyse, to reason logically and to spot errors in the reasoning of others, the study of philosophy (at least in the analytical tradition) is highly recommended."

I do not contest this claim. Philosophy is chief amongst the humanities subjects that hones ones academic and cognitive ability. Yet this is not a technical skill, it is a soft skill. Like being able to write well or explain ideas vividly. While these are undoubtely valuable skills to have in any job, they are also a skills that one cannot provide empirical evidence in C.V. form. For example, If a systems analylist applies for a job in, uh... analysing systems. His employer (in South Africa) is not going to care if he has studied philosophy or not. The company our hypothetical student is applying too is not going to list "being a philosophy graduate is a plus" in the job listing. In short, this valuable skill that philosophy hones is far too transparent to be marketable. 

However, maybe i'm wrong. The departmental website also provides a link for prospective students to an article by the guardian, found here. To summarise the article, it basically says the amount of philosophy graduates is on the rise and employers are more readily hiring philosophy graduates for almost any job that requires the proper use of a brain (obviously football and acting is out).

I dont contest this claim either. But here is were my careful phrasing of the title of this post comes in. I do not think this to be the case in South Africa. Amongst other things, Philosophy provides one with very deep knowledge in the sense that you can provide an analytical philosopher with a problem, tell him the rules and parameters and he can tell you what needs to be done to solve the problem, he will cross the t's and dot the i's. Down to every minute detail. While this is useful in first world countries were quality is everything, in a 3rd world, poverty stricken, country it is not. When the resources are thin and people are hungry and there is pressure to deliver, people dont want the t's crossed and the i's dotted. They just want the damn thing done to an 'adequate' level. A standard general hospital in south africa might find need for lawyers and doctors and administrative staff, but with 3rd world restrictions they cannot find space in the budget for a medical ethics consultant, which is the kind of job that directly applies philosophy (as opposed to indirectly by the systems analyst having honed analytical skills.

Furthermore, europe and america have a far more diverse employment opportunities (such as medical ethics consultant). Look through the career times, gumtree or whatever medium you use to browse jobs and you will find that for the most part, our beautiful country has very generic jobs on offer. Look through the jobs on offer in europe and you find many more opportunities. For example, where else could you use your philosophy degree to a get a job at the giant gaming company known as Blizzard Entertainment but europe (or indeed the United States).

 To explicity state my point, the future of a Philosophy Graduate lies in the realm of the first world. Precisely because the first world can afford to "go the extra mile" so to speak in whatever it is they do.

 

The only realistic option, then, for the South African Philosophy graduate is to either use the degree as a stepping stone to, for example, LLB or to become an Academic and teach the great subject to future generations of south african philosophy graduates and continue the philosophical race.

Comments

Re: State of the South African Philosophy Graduate

George | 25/08/2010, 14:38

We're the dying children of Africa. Also, philosophy enables one to argue better with traffic officials. [And parents.]
Add comment
 authimage

calendar

  • « August 2010 »
    Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa Su
                1
    2 3 4 5 6 7 8
    9 10 11 12 13 14 15
    16 17 18 19 20 21 22
    23 24 25 26 27 28 29
    30 31          

search


recently...

archives

Categories

Syndicate

    RSS 0.90 RSS 1.0 RSS 2.0 Atom 0.3