Where Are You On The "Digital Highway"?

Digital people Trackbacks (0) comments (1)   

We’re about to move between data collection phases for our project. Having done about 100 initial telephone interviews and about 35 follow up telephone interviews (well not all personally we have been very ably assisted by Haley, Mav and Zolani here),  we are now about to embark on the focus group phase. This is very exciting as it gives us an opportunity to delve even deeper into some of the issues emerging.

We are using Bourdieu’s theory of field, capital and habitus with a particular aim to find out more students “technological habitus”. A tricky thing to do as some researcher’s tell us what a hard concept it is to operationalise (see Maton) whilst others lament the un theoretical methods in which people are starting to appropriate the terminology  (See Reay) 

We had a really useful meeting with our colleague Lucia  on Thurs and she gave us a great idea of using a metaphor as a way of getting students to unpack their dispositions, values, views etc about  ICTs in their lives as a way of getting not just at habitus but also at other forms of capital (which is key to understanding habitus).

Now obviously I’m missing out on a whole lot here (skipping chunks of the methods, theory and focus group process). But just to explore something -  if you were to describe the technological part  of your life in terms of this metaphor what would you say?

Imagine the digital highway ( yes I know it’s a very 90’s / early internet metaphor, but it could still work .....)

  • What does this road look like to you?
  • Where does it come from and where is it going?
  • Are you on the road? Where are you positioned?
  • Why you are going on the journey
  • How are you travelling?
  • Which direction are you going in
  • Who is traveling with you?
  • What are you taking along with you?
  • What else could you tell us about your journey along that road?

BTW - hows this image? A digital highway originating straight out of South Africa. I always knew we were the centre for the digital world (lol)

digital highway image from www.worldofstock.com/

Technology Makes You Wiser?

Digital people Trackbacks (0) comments (3)   
I'll have some more of that please! Whilst busy with paper unpacking and deconstructing Prensky's much espoused notion of the "digital native", I decided to go back to the source for some more fuel for the fire, so to speak, and came across this paper.
H. Sapiens Digital: From Digital Immigrants and Digital Natives to Digital Wisdom"As we move further into the 21st century, the digital native/digital immigrant paradigm created by Marc Prensky in 2001 is becoming less relevant. In this article, Prensky suggests that we should focus instead on the development of what he calls "digital wisdom." Arguing that digital technology can make us not just smarter but truly wiser."
 So now Prensky has moved from a colonial metaphor to an evolutionary one. For an ex archaeologist this is very amusing. Its no longer a matter of merely being in or out of the group but the implicit notions of technology equalling betterment, advancement, advantage, opportunities for the future and the evolutionary connotations of natural selection and extinction that this conjurs up are more than a bit scary.  I am reminded how essential it is (especially as people immersed in technology) to avoid an overly deterministic view of the essential role of technology let alone a view of technology users as having a wisdom above non technology users.  Ok perhaps I have been a little cynical about Prensky (because I have inherent problems with the metaphor).  If one registers for Innovate online and reads the whole article what he ends up talking about is Critical Digital Literacy   (not a new concept) but I fear the way the popular media somehow seems to pick up on “Prenskyisms” that the Homo sapiens digital will be haunting us before too long.